barshad.
Contact
SEO strategy & costs

How to hire an SEO specialist: 12 questions that separate experts from talkers

Whether you are a founder choosing a consultant or a hiring team interviewing for an in-house role, these twelve questions reveal how a candidate thinks, what they have actually done, and whether they can turn rankings into revenue.

How to hire an SEO specialist: 12 questions that separate experts from talkers
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Ask for evidence: Search Console screenshots, before-and-after URLs and what changed.
  • Strong candidates talk about diagnosis and priorities before tactics.
  • They connect rankings to enquiries and revenue, and they explain trade-offs.
  • Be cautious of guarantees, secret methods and vague answers about links.

Almost anyone can say “SEO specialist” on a profile. Telling a real expert from a confident talker is harder, especially if search is not your own field. The good news is that experts and talkers answer questions very differently.

These twelve questions work whether you are a founder choosing a consultant or a hiring team interviewing for an in-house role. Listen for how the person thinks, not for jargon.

Questions about diagnosis

1. “Before you suggest anything, what would you look at first on our website?”

Good answer: Search Console and Analytics data, how the site is indexed, which pages drive enquiries, what competitors rank with, and the business goals. Weak answer: an immediate list of tactics such as “we will build links and write blogs”.

2. “Our traffic dropped 30% last month. How would you find out why?”

Look for a structured approach: check whether the drop is real or a tracking change, isolate which pages, searches and devices fell, compare with known Google updates and site changes, then form hypotheses. Experts narrow the problem before they fix it.

3. “What would you not do on our website, and why?”

Prioritisation is a senior skill. A strong candidate can explain what is not worth the effort right now.

Questions about evidence

4. “Show me a result you are proud of, and what changed to cause it.”

Ask to see Search Console or Analytics on screen, with dates. Then ask what specifically was done in that period. Real experience comes with details: page types, problems, decisions and setbacks.

5. “Tell me about a project that did not work.”

Everyone who has done real SEO has one. Honest answers, and what they learned, are a strong signal.

6. “How do you report progress?”

Good reporting connects work to outcomes: indexed pages, impressions and clicks for priority pages, rankings for commercial searches, and leads or revenue from organic search. Rankings alone are not enough.

Questions about method

You want to hear about search intent, keyword-to-URL mapping and avoiding pages that compete with each other.

Credible answers talk about earning mentions through useful content, partnerships, digital PR and local relationships. Be wary of packages of links at fixed prices.

9. “What changes when AI answers appear above search results?”

A current specialist can explain AI Overviews and assistants in plain language, separate evidence from hype, and connect it to fundamentals: indexable, clear, trusted content and a consistent business identity.

10. “How would you work with our developers and writers?”

SEO only matters once it is implemented. Look for clear specifications, tickets developers can act on, content briefs and testing before release.

Questions about fit

11. “What do you need from us to succeed?”

Access, decision speed, developer time, subject-matter input and realistic expectations. Experts state these up front.

12. “What would the first 30 days look like?”

The answer should be concrete: access and tracking checks, an audit, quick fixes, priorities agreed, the first improvements shipped.

Agency, freelancer or in-house?

Option Strengths Watch out for
Independent specialist Senior attention, direct communication, flexible scope Capacity for very large programmes
Agency Many hands, several disciplines in one place Who actually does the work after the sales meeting
In-house hire Deep knowledge of your business, always available Needs tools, support and a clear mandate to change the website

Many companies combine them: an in-house marketer with a senior specialist for strategy, audits and reviews.

The real cost of a wrong hire

The fee is the smallest part. A wrong choice can cost months of lost time, a website damaged by low-quality links or a careless migration, and a team that stops believing SEO works. That is why the evidence and diagnosis questions above matter more than price or presentation.

A practical task instead of a test

For in-house roles and larger engagements, a short paid task tells you more than any interview. Good options:

  • Review one key page of your website and explain the three changes that would matter most.
  • Look at your Search Console performance report together and explain what stands out.
  • Write a brief for a new service page: target searches, intent, outline, internal links and success measure.

Keep it under two hours and pay for it. You are evaluating judgement, not asking for free work.

Hiring for a role: what to look for by level

Level Should be able to
Executive Run checks, optimise pages from a brief, report clearly
Specialist Diagnose problems, plan content and technical fixes, work directly with developers
Senior or lead Set strategy, prioritise across teams, lead people, connect search to revenue and explain it to leadership

Questions a candidate should ask you

Strong candidates interview you too. Expect questions about your customers, margins, sales process, past SEO work, access to developers and how decisions are made. If someone has no questions about your business, they are planning to sell you a standard package.

Red flags

  • Guaranteed rankings or timelines.
  • “Secret” methods they cannot explain.
  • No access to your own data, or accounts in their name.
  • Results they cannot show with dates and context.
  • Talk of tricks to “beat” Google instead of serving searchers.

A simple scorecard

Score each candidate from 1 to 5 on diagnosis, evidence, method, communication and business understanding. The highest total is usually the right choice, even if they are not the cheapest.

If you would like to run these questions on me, I am happy to. You can see my experience, browse my work or book a short call.

Frequently asked questions

Should I hire an agency, a freelancer or an in-house specialist?

A specialist or consultant suits businesses that need senior thinking and flexible scope. An agency suits large programmes that need many hands. In-house makes sense when search is central to the business and there is enough ongoing work.

What results should I expect in the first three months?

Clear diagnosis, fixed technical blockers, a prioritised roadmap, the first improved or new pages, and working measurement. Large traffic changes usually come later, although technical fixes can show early movement.

Is a certification important?

Certifications show learning, not results. Ask for evidence of outcomes and how they were achieved.

How do I check claimed results?

Ask to see the data in Search Console or Analytics during a call, with dates and the URL or property name visible, and ask what specifically changed during that period.

Barshad Sitoula
ABOUT THE AUTHORBarshad Sitoula

SEO specialist and digital marketer based in Dubai with 7+ years across technical SEO, content strategy and WordPress development. Former Senior SEO Lead.

Prefer email? contact@barshadsitoula.com

Barshad’s assistant

Automated assistant · online

LET’S FIND YOUR NEXT STEP

How can I help today?

I’m Barshad’s automated assistant, not Barshad himself. Ask about services and prices, explore his work, plan a project, or book a free call with him.

Start with your question. No form to fill in.

Checking conversation availability…

Enter to send
About this assistant & privacy

Answers use the public portfolio and general SEO guidance.

AI can make mistakes. This chat cannot crawl a site or confirm a booking. Conversation history stays in this page until you clear it or leave. It is not automatically sent to Barshad.

Shift+Enter adds a new line.